LoansGenerator

Consolidation Break-Even Calculator

This calculator finds the break-even APR: the rate above which a consolidation loan costs more in total than the way you pay your debts now. It counts the origination fee and uses what you actually pay each month, not just the minimums.

Find your break-even rate

Enter your current debts, what you pay each month, and the loan you are considering. Results update as you type. This calculator runs in your browser and does not send the numbers you enter.

From $1 to $250,000. Up to 10 debts.

0% to 99.9%. Use 0% for a promotional balance and fill in the promotion fields.

It should be more than one month's interest.

Leave blank if there is no promotion.

If you are already paying more than the minimums, enter your real total. It changes the answer a lot. Left blank, it uses the sum of your minimums.

Payoff order if paying more than minimums
Is any of this debt secured, such as an auto loan or a mortgage?

Left blank, it uses your total balances. From $1,000 to $100,000.

The yearly rate before the fee. With the fee counted, the APR has to be from 5.99% to 35.99%.

6 to 144 months (6 months to 12 years).

From 0% to 12%. Many lenders charge one.

How the lender charges the fee

Your comparison

This calculator needs JavaScript. The formulas and the worked example on this page show the same math.

How this is calculated

  1. Current plan, one month at a time: each balance grows by a month of interest, balance × APR ÷ 12, using the promotional APR for the promotional months left and the APR after the promotion from then on. Interest is not rounded month to month.
  2. Your monthly payment is then spent: the minimum goes to every debt except the first one in your payoff order (highest current APR first, or smallest balance first, with ties kept in the order you entered), and the rest goes to that first debt, with anything left over passing to the next. A blank monthly payment means the sum of your minimums. This repeats until every balance is zero, for up to 50 years, and the interest is added up and rounded to the cent. When your monthly payment is the sum of your minimums, the same comparison is also shown at $100 a month more.
  3. New loan amount: the amount the loan must deliver is your total balances, or the amount you enter, kept between $1,000 and $100,000. With the fee deducted from the proceeds you borrow that amount ÷ (1 - fee rate); with the fee added to the balance you borrow that amount × (1 + fee rate). The amount borrowed is shown rounded to the cent, but the payment is worked out on the unrounded amount.
  4. New loan payment = amount borrowed × r ÷ (1 - (1 + r)^-n), where r is the interest rate divided by 12 and n is the term in months (at 0%, the amount borrowed ÷ n), rounded to the cent, half up. Total paid = that payment × n. The cost of consolidating = total paid minus the amount the loan delivers. The difference from the current plan is the cost of consolidating minus the current plan's interest, both as shown, rounded to the cent.
  5. If the loan delivers less than your total balances, it clears them in your payoff order, and what is left stays on the current plan, paid with the larger of its minimums or what remains of your current payment after the loan payment. The interest on that part is added to the cost of consolidating, and you are debt free when both the loan and that part are paid off.
  6. Break-even: the interest rate between 0.01% and 40% at which the cost of consolidating equals the interest on your current plan, holding the term and fee fixed, found by halving the search range over and over. If no rate in that range makes them equal, the result says so.
  7. That rate is shown as an APR: the yearly rate at which the loan payments, discounted month by month, add up to the amount the loan delivers, so the fee is counted. For the break-even this uses the payment before rounding to the cent; for the loan you entered, the rounded payment. With no fee, the APR and the interest rate are the same. Rates are shown to two decimal places.

Example: three cards totaling $14,000 ($1,200 at 18.99%, $4,800 at 26.99%, $8,000 at 22.49%), paid at $555 a month, highest APR first, compared with a 48-month loan at an 18.99% interest rate with a 5% fee deducted from the proceeds.

Current plan: debt free in35 months
Current plan: interest$5,319.29
New loan: amount borrowed$14,736.84 (fee $736.84)
New loan: monthly payment$440.56
New loan: total paid$21,146.88
Cost of consolidating$7,146.88
Consolidating compared with the current plan$1,827.59 more
Break-even APR16.79% (interest rate 13.97%)

The comparison keeps each minimum payment the same every month and does not include new charges on the cards after they are paid off.

Loans Generator may be paid when you click or submit a request through this link. This does not change what we report.

See personal loan optionsTakes you to the Loans Generator request form.

The math, shown

Cost of the new loan

When the fee is deducted from proceeds, the loan amount is the debt you need cleared divided by one minus the fee rate. The monthly payment is that loan amount × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n), where r is the interest rate divided by 12 and n is the number of months. The total cost of the new loan is the payment times n, minus the debt it actually retires.

That subtraction matters. If you need $14,000 of debt cleared and the fee is 5%, you must borrow $14,736.84 to net $14,000. The $736.84 fee is a cost, and the honest comparison charges it to the new loan.

Cost of the status quo

Simulate month by month rather than using a closed-form shortcut, because payoff order, promotional expiries, and freed-up minimums all change the answer:

  1. Accrue one month of interest on each debt at its current APR.
  2. Pay the minimum on every debt except the target.
  3. Apply the remaining budget to the target debt.
  4. When a debt reaches zero, roll its payment into the next target.
  5. Repeat until all balances are zero. Sum the interest.

Break-even

The calculator searches for the loan rate at which the new loan's total cost equals the interest on your current plan, holding the term and fee fixed.

Representative example. For a $5,000 loan at a 10% APR over 36 months, the monthly repayment would be $161.34. Over the term, the total repayment would amount to $5,808.24, with $808.24 in interest. The loan terms range from 6 months to 12 years, with APRs between 5.99% and 35.99%. The exact rate you receive depends on factors like your creditworthiness, loan size, and repayment schedule. Better rates are typically offered to those with excellent credit.

Worked example

Three cards, $14,000 total:

DebtBalanceAPRMinimum
Card A$1,20018.99%$35
Card B$4,80026.99%$120
Card C$8,00022.49%$200

Minimums total $355. Assume this person is actually paying $555 a month, highest APR first.

Status quo: debt free in 35 months, $5,319.29 in interest, $19,319.29 paid in total.

Consolidation at an 18.99% interest rate (21.93% APR with the fee) over 48 months with a 5% origination fee: borrow $14,736.84 to net $14,000, payment $440.56, total paid $21,146.88. That is $1,827.59 more than doing nothing new, despite a lower rate than two of the three cards.

Break-even for that structure: an APR of 16.79%, which with the 5% fee means an interest rate of 13.97%. Below it, consolidating costs less; above it, it costs more.

The break-even is highly sensitive to the term, which is the finding most calculators bury:

New loan structureBreak-even interest rateBreak-even APR
48 months, 5% origination fee13.97%16.79%
48 months, no origination fee16.79%16.79%
36 months, 5% origination fee18.52%22.27%

Same debts, same person. Moving from 48 to 36 months raises the break-even APR from 16.79% to 22.27%. The fee does not change the break-even APR, because an APR already counts the fee; it only lowers the interest rate you need.

The risk the arithmetic cannot capture

The calculator compares two payment schedules. It cannot model the behavior that decides most consolidation outcomes, which is what happens to the cards after they are paid off. If the balances come back, the borrower now has the cards and the loan.

Sources

Do not sell my personal information

Certain U.S. state laws, including the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and the California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA), may give you the right to opt out of the “sale” or “sharing” of personal information for cross-context behavioral advertising. LoansGenerator is committed to honoring valid opt-out requests. When you confirm below, we will record your preference using a cookie in your browser. If you clear cookies or use a different browser or device, you may need to submit your choice again. For more detail, see our Privacy Policy.